Dogfood: Simon Brooke's blog

Reviews


The polemic, as detective story --
Steig Larsson's first novel looks like a detective story. Well, it looks like that because it is one. But, at a deeper level, it isn't...
Not quite a chip off the old block --
In 1936, Pierre-Jules Boulanger asked his engineers to design him a 'toute petite voiture', and they responded in style. They designed a car with flair, with elan, with chic, and with a certain joi de vivre. Can their present- day successors do as well?
The Witcher: Story telling of a high order --
I've been engaged in discussion recently about whether fantasy fiction can ever be literature - needless to say, I argue that it can. Can a video game be literature, or at least art of high quality? Experience the Witcher, and find out
George Lucas meets Anne McTorturedAdolescentCaffrey --
Eragon, Christopher Paolini, Corgi Books 2005
Spectacle and Courage --
The Extended Edition DVD set of Peter Jackson's movie of the Return of the King is just out, and I've spent altogether too much of this week immersed in it. Here's my thoughts.
Tigana --
Guy Gavriel Kay is the fantasy writer's fantasy writer. This is currently my favourite novel.
Dragon Blood --
Tolkien's King is inherently good; the Return of the King is an icon of the return of good governance. But Patricia Briggs is more subtle and is exploring the genre in new ways ISBN 0-441-01008-3
Dragon Bones --
This ought to be an awful book. Any literary agent worth their salt would have taken one glance at the synopsis and urged - begged - the author to write something different.
The Da Vinci Code --
If ever a book screamed out 'make me a movie' it's this one. The locations are opulent. The pace is frenetic. The set pieces are highly cinematic. Frankly, I hope a film is made of it. It will probably be a good film. It's a dreadful book.